The assessments followed a CNN report citing seven US officials who said intelligence indicated Iran was developing plans to potentially target senior Trump administration officials in Washington with a dirty bomb or chemical weapon.
"Dirty bomb is not typically what you would use to assassinate someone," said David Albright, a physicist and president of the Institute for Science and International Security.
Farzin Nadimi, a senior fellow at the Washington Institute specializing in Iran's military affairs, assessed the likelihood of an attack as "low to very low," citing operational difficulties and the prospect of US retaliation.
Two sources cited by CNN said the planning included specific locations and targets, although there was no evidence that Iranian leaders had decided to proceed. Officials differed over whether personnel were already in place.
The White House said there were "no credible threats to the homeland" at the time. President Donald Trump said Tuesday that Washington was investigating the information and taking the possibility seriously.
Iran denied the allegations, while Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin described the planning as "aspirational."
Iran's chemical-weapons history
Iran's history of acquiring and transferring unconventional weapons provides grounds for taking the warnings seriously, Behnam Ben Taleblu, senior director of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies' Iran Program, said.
"These are threats that do need to be taken seriously," Taleblu said. "Conversely, the intelligence leaks and the sources should also be scrutinized."
Taleblu cited Iran's past transfers of chemical weapons to Muammar Gaddafi's Libya.
US State Department compliance reports have identified Iran's failure to declare chemical-weapons transfers during the Libya-Chad war as a violation of the Chemical Weapons Convention.
A 2019 report cited chemical-filled artillery projectiles and aerial bombs transferred to Libya, alongside chemical mortar rounds assessed to be of Iranian origin found in Iraq, as evidence supporting Washington's assessment that Iran had filled and possessed chemical weapons.
A subsequent report identified Iran's pursuit of pharmaceutical-based agents for offensive purposes as another compliance violation.
Despite that history, Taleblu did not regard the latest warnings as necessarily signaling a change in Iran's military doctrine.
"I think this is a lot more of the same," he said.
Would a dirty bomb be effective?
The alleged assassination objective raises questions about the choice of weapon, particularly whether a radiological device would be effective against individual targets.
A dirty bomb combines conventional explosives with radioactive material. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says its primary immediate danger generally comes from the explosion, although radioactive contamination can create additional health risks.
Such a device could force evacuations and spread fear, but would be less suited to killing a particular individual, Albright said.
"In terms of an assassination method, I wouldn't consider it very effective," he said.
Chemical agents could be more effective for targeting individuals, Albright argued, citing research published by his institute in 2024 identifying evidence of Iranian work on delivering pharmaceutical-based agents using drones.
Whether that work produced an operational capability or was connected to a specific US attack plan remained unclear.
"I think it's also important to keep in mind that the story said there was no imminent threat," Albright added.
Operational obstacles and retaliation risks
Beyond the choice of weapon, carrying out an attack would require access to materials, reliable personnel and the ability to evade US security measures.
Iranian intelligence services could potentially construct a crude radiological device if they obtained the necessary material inside the United States, Nadimi assessed.
"The likelihood I believe is low to very low, given the risks associated with such an action and the high possibility of retaliation," he said.
Questions about operational readiness also concerned Mark Fowler, a former CIA operations officer with extensive experience involving Iran, who questioned who was discussing the alleged attack and how far preparations had advanced.
"It's not clear to me that they actually have that in hand at this point," Fowler said, referring to the required materials.
CNN reported that Iranian communications suggested bomb-making materials were already inside the United States. Officials disputed the credibility of that information, although some considered it likely that materials had been positioned in advance.
Nadimi considered domestic acquisition theoretically possible, while Albright emphasized US accounting and security measures that make obtaining radioactive material more difficult.
A 2021 National Academies study identified vulnerabilities involving some civilian radioactive sources and warned that even relatively small radioactive releases could have lasting socioeconomic consequences.
The warnings could also strain US security resources even without an attack, Mike Pregent, a former intelligence officer who has testified before Congress about Iran's overseas terrorism networks, said.
"They've already got everybody spinning up on it," Pregent said.
Any radiological or chemical-weapons attack could also harden American public opinion against the Islamic Republic and provoke severe retaliation, Nadimi said.
The reported consideration of such an operation, however, "does not show a decision is made to act," he added.