ANALYSIS

Trump hits Mideast with sonic boom of a Gaza takeover plan

Arash Aalaei
Arash Aalaei

Iran International Congressional Reporter

A Palestinian man, who was displaced at Israel's order during the war, speaks with a child after returning to his destroyed house, January 28, 2025
A Palestinian man, who was displaced at Israel's order during the war, speaks with a child after returning to his destroyed house, January 28, 2025

In a press conference that few saw coming, US president Donald Trump stood alongside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to announce a jaw-dropping plan to take over and rebuild Gaza.

As Trump spoke, Netanyahu’s eyes darted back and forth between Trump and the gathered press, perhaps looking out for the potential fallout.

In a region where diplomacy often plays out at full volume, Trump’s announcement shattered the sonic barrier, leaving both allies and adversaries scrambling to adjust.

The Disrupter

The announcement was just the latest chapter in Trump's long history of disruption.

The man who started his 2016 presidential campaign polling near 1% in the Republican primaries soon bulldozed through the political establishment, knocking out seasoned contenders like Jeb Bush and Ted Cruz.

His unexpected victory over Hillary Clinton that year defied political logic. Even after losing the 2020 election, Trump managed to disrupted the system again, emerging in 2024 as a force that reshaped American politics yet again.

The Real Estate Mogul

Trump’s vision for rebuilding Gaza brings to mind his early triumphs as a real estate mogul, most famously in the Wollman Rink saga.

For six years, New York City bureaucrats had floundered in their attempts to restore the iconic Central Park ice skating rink, wasting millions of dollars.

On May 31, 1986, Trump declared in an interview with The New York Times, “I don’t want my name attached to losers. So far the Wollman Rink has been one of the great losers. I’ll make it a winner.”

He did take over the project shortly after, completing ahead of schedule and under budget. The rink became a thriving tourist attraction and a successful business, much loved by the city's residents.

To this day, Trump’s association with Wollman Rink remains visible — check the rink’s website, and boom, there's Trump’s unmistakable logo.

Much like Wollman Rink, Gaza is seen by many as a project doomed to failure, weighed down by decades of entrenched problems. But it’s precisely the kind of challenge that energizes Trump.

If nothing else, Trump’s announcement alone has already made people rethink what’s possible.

The Dealmaker

Trump’s proposal sparked reactions among Palestinian including those in the United State.

While some in Gaza, driven by their dire circumstances, may like the idea of relocation to other countries, many view the suggestion as an affront to their rights and aspirations

Tump's plan for Gaza has also pitted him against an ensemble of Middle Eastern strongmen: Egypt’s Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, Saudi Arabia’s Mohammed bin Salman, Jordan’s King Abdullah, Netanyahu himself, and Turkey’s Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

But Trump’s most strategic target is none of the above. It’s the Ayatollah in Iran. The Gaza plan seeks to isolate the Islamic Republic and break the cycle of dysfunction that has plagued the region for decades.

Trump understands that sometimes ideas matter more than execution. By planting this idea in people’s heads, he’s already forced conversations that many considered impossible.

Whether or not the US ever commits to take over and Gaza, the ripple effects of his announcement are undeniable. Suddenly, everyone is talking about Gaza in a way they weren’t before.

The Ayatollah

While Trump’s plan is disruptive, it coincides with another seismic shift: the slow unraveling of the long-held dream of Iran's supreme leader Ali Khamenei: to push America out of the Middle East.

The Islamic Republic’s overreach in its quest for regional dominance has alienated many of its neighbors, at times pushing Arabs and Israelis closer together.

Instead of driving America out, Khamenei now finds itself in the midst of a conversation about a hypothetical take over of Gaza by the United States.

Trump, ever the disruptor, thrives in the chaos he creates. Whether it’s a New York ice rink or the Gaza Strip, he knows how to break through the noise — and make everyone listen.